Sacramento Brew in Review

Posted on February 2, 2011 – 11:47 AM | by OldManFoster
  • Share

By Ed Carroll

When Sacramento Valley’s early inhabitants found their way to John Sutter’s outpost, brewing was hardly a new concept. As in Europe, the American colonies boasted breweries aplenty and the fine art of home brewing was just another household ritual alongside washing the linens, cooking and tending the garden.  Understandably, as dreams of gold and agrarian utopias lured the masses westward, beer naturally came along for the ride. So it was that Sacramento’s pioneer brewers came to ply their trade among the city’s burgeoning population and those en route to the mines.

The story of brewing in the West is complex and commands a much larger space than has been allotted here. Nonetheless, remember that brewing beer (and alcohol production in general) in Sacramento was as essential to local commerce as any other enterprise and much more than most.

Sacramento’s early breweries were situated in shabby wood and canvas structures and often lasted but a few months before their proprietors pulled up stakes in search of greener pastures. Not all succumbed to the perils of gold rush economics, however; a handful of breweries emerged from the confusion of the gold rush to make Sacramento California’s second largest brewing center after San Francisco. Much of this success can be attributed to the skill and resourcefulness of Sacramento’s German population. In their effort to preserve their cultural identity (and turn a tidy profit while they were at it) these stalwarts doggedly set about replicating their native brews in a foreign locale amidst a paucity of quality ingredients.

Buffalo Brewery under construction, 1879. Image Courtesy Sacramento Room

Beer in early 1850s Sacramento was undoubtedly a palatable concoction, but surely lacked the characteristic quality and flavor ushered in with the commencement of local and regional hop growing in the early 1860s, and the introduction of artificial refrigeration a decade or so later.  There were many constraints on Sacramento’s brewers during the 1850s, not the least of which was the absence of fresh hops. Quality hops are imperative to a successful brew.  During these times, New York and Europe dominated the hop industry and our city’s pioneer brewer had to make do with hops that made the long dusty trek across country or aboard moldy, unsanitary ships carrying goods and passengers to the gold fields.  The upside was that unlike those brewers on the East Coast nestled among the bustle and filth of the big city, Sacramento’s maverick brewer had plenty of good water on hand to offset his use of less than desirable ingredients.

Perhaps the most crucial factor preventing Germans from replicating their native lager was the intense heat of the valley summer. Again, the conditions between the rest of the brewing universe and Sacramento must be understood to grasp the local industry’s evolution. Without the benefit of refrigeration and icy winters like those in the East, Midwest and, to some degree San Francisco, it became a formidable challenge to produce lager (a cold fermenting beer).  In contrast, the prevalence of warmer temperatures produced the desirable conditions for ale production, resulting in a brewers’ quandary: to abandon traditional lager brewing techniques or settle for a new interpretation of lager? The result was one of ingenuity and compromise.

Pioneer brewer Frank Ruhstaller, image Courtesy of the Sacramento Room

Fermenting lager yeast at warm temperatures produced a wholly different beer, now known as California common or steam beer. This style went on to enormous popularity even after true lager production was made possible through a variety of technical improvements. Lager soon joined the ranks of ale and steam and eventually surpassed both styles in popularity and production, nationally and locally.

The final piece of the brewing puzzle was the cultivation of local hops. Around 1857, New Hampshire’s Flint brothers established the state’s first commercial hop yard south of Broadway as part of their many horticultural experiments. Initially the two brothers had a difficult time convincing local brewers that their hops were as good, if not better, than their Eastern and European counterparts, but after a few trials it was obvious that the Flints were onto something. Others took notice and also began to take advantage of the tremendous agricultural potential afforded by the region’s weather and alluvial soil. Now with a plentiful supply of local hops on hand, Sacramento’s brewer could produce the beer he had originally envisaged and most importantly, Sacramento Valley hops earned a worldwide reputation among brewers for their quality and flavor.

Over a dozen or more breweries opened in Sacramento between 1849 and 1865.  At the time the typical local brewery was characterized by modest two-story brick buildings with basements (for fermentation) rather than the threadbare wood and canvas affairs favored a decade earlier. Brewing, like the city itself, had become solidified and regulated, allowing brewers to expand production and distribution. The chief result of this evolution was the influx of wealth among brewery operators. They in turn invested in any number of ventures ranging from agriculture and banks, real estate, saloons and, of course, brewery improvements.

Breweries came and went over the next 60 years and Sacramento always managed to support its local brewer despite the encroachment of large national shipping brands including Pabst and Budweiser. Innovations such as artificial refrigeration and the refrigerated rail car, bottling lines, advertising and numerous other technical advancements forced small brewers across the nation to either consolidate to meet the high expenses associated with these changes or to simply close up shop. Rather than fold, several Sacramento brewers consolidated their money and equipment to compete on a larger scale. The result was the Sacramento Brewing Company formed by brewing magnate and firebrand Frank Ruhstaller and his associates in 1892. Soon thereafter, many of these same entrepreneurs masterminded Sacramento’s crown jewel, the Buffalo Brewery, choosing to manage it under the moniker Buffalo Brewing Company.

Alas, all good things must come to an end and local brewing was no exception. Curtailed by the Volstead Act of 1919, commonly known as Prohibition, commercial brewing ceased in Sacramento for the first time since 1849. The world of post-prohibition brewing was dominated by new and expensive technology, leaving no room for the upstart. Brewing in the capital city would never return to the production levels sustained throughout the 19th Century and the modern brewing industry eclipsed the last vestiges of the city’s pioneer brewing roots. Buffalo Brewery attempted to regain its former glory but despite strong financial backing, it eventually lost its footing against the same national brands it had competed against in the latter 19th and early 20th centuries.

Of course, telling the entire complex story of Sacramento’s noble brewing heritage within this confined space is simply not possible but it is important to remember those souls who diligently worked amidst the primitive conditions of 19th Century Sacramento to continue the age old tradition and science of brewing.  This city may have drastically changed since its inception, but local beer and brewing culture allows us to remain connected to those parched souls that inhabited our homes and roamed our streets over 150 years ago.

Tags: , , ,

  1. 18 Responses to “Sacramento Brew in Review”

  2. avatar

    By Rick on Feb 6, 2011 | Reply

    Fantastic piece – Thank you, Ed!

  3. avatar

    By Tod Ruhstaller on Feb 17, 2011 | Reply

    Dear Mr. Carroll:
    VERY much enjoyed both this MIDTOWN MONTHLY article, as well as your SACRAMENTO’S BREWERIES book. The latter was passed along to me by my cousin, Charlotte Ruhstaller Gilmore. My three brother’s and I (all Stocktonians) are the grandsons of David Jacob Ruhstaller (the gentleman in the photo on page 28 of your book–and misidentified as Frank Ruhstaller, Jr.)
    I’ve often wondered what beer today would most closely resemble the taste of Ruhstaller’s Gilt Edge Lager? Any thoughts.

    Tod Ruhstaller
    CEO & Curator of History
    The Haggin Museum
    Stockton, CA

  4. avatar

    By Ed on Feb 23, 2011 | Reply

    Tod, I wish I knew what the brew might have tasted like but it is hard to guess. One of life’s unsolvable mysteries I am afraid. If only the recipe was hiding somewhere . .


  5. avatar

    By Find Magic on Mar 3, 2011 | Reply

    Awesome, article I had no idea there were so many Breweries that opened and closed in Sacramento. I love my Rubicon and River city on occasion. The best beers are found in Breweries for sure.

  6. avatar

    By Shaun Harrington on Aug 30, 2011 | Reply

    I have an 7′ tall amber bottle with the ceramic Buffalo Brewing cap still attached… seems to be in good shape. If anyone is interested in acquiring please send a message to

  7. avatar

    By Tom on Apr 19, 2012 | Reply

    I saw a report a while ago on TV about someone who wrote a book about Beer Brewing History in Sacramento.I believe a Sac State student. Does anyone know the name of the book and where I can buy it.

  8. avatar

    By Gee Whiz on Apr 23, 2012 | Reply

    Sure can, Tom! The author is Midtown Monthly contributor Ed Carroll and the book is called “Sacramento’s Breweries.” They always try to keep it in stock at Beer’s Books at 916 S. You could probably find it at Time Tested or the Book Collector as well.

  9. avatar

    By John DuPriest on Nov 30, 2012 | Reply

    Tod, I have one of those large Buffalo Brewing trays in very fine condition. I think it is approx 28-30″ in diameter and is the one with the Black Hired girl in low-cut blouse.
    I have a couple of photos if you give me an address.

    John DuPriest 916/933-2185

  10. avatar

    By Tod Ruhstaller on Apr 2, 2014 | Reply

    Dear John:
    Sorry about never getting back to you, but after posting forgot all about this until I was just doing some research and saw you comment. Would appreciate seeing the images.
    My address is
    1201 N. Pershing Ave.
    Stockton, CA 95203

  11. avatar

    By Joan Leach on Feb 16, 2015 | Reply

    In going through my Aunt’s belongings I found two green bottles. One has a BBC logo stating Buffalo Brewing Co. S.F.Agency with BBC monogram. The other is hand etched “Buffalo Agency S.F.” I don’t see any date stamps. One bottle has a cork attached. What can you tell me about these?

  12. avatar

    By Sharon Kilgore on Apr 22, 2015 | Reply


    I am in the produce business and worked for many years at businesses, including our own, at the Sacramento Farmers Market on 5th Street, off Broadway in Sacramento. The SFM opened in 1937, however, there was a brick building there which housed a restaurant which is rumored to have been built in the 1890’s. There are also stories of a speakeasy with secret exits, etc.

    I could never reconcile the opening of the market with a speakeasy because of the dates….but maybe a gambling room. There are remnants of an oak dance floor and paintings of musicians on the walls upstairs but no one seems to know where they came from. Recently, someone said the building was a brewery and that is why there is a railroad track behind the building.

    So, the last comment led me to your website. Possibly they have their stories mixed up and are thinking of the Buffalo Brewery on 19th and Broadway? Do you have any information about a brewery on the west side of 5th Street just past First Avenue. The Sacramento Farmers Market’s address is 2630 5th Street. I am attempting to find information about the restaurant and what the building was used for before 1937.

    Any information, including how to get your Sacramento Breweries book, would be appreciated. Thanks,

    Sharon Kilgore

  13. avatar

    By helene suess on May 7, 2015 | Reply

    I have often looked at an old card mailed to my Grandfather in
    July 1911 from your company. It was the “Message of July”. It is part of California history which I truly enjoy.

  14. avatar

    By Anastasia Fonger on Aug 15, 2016 | Reply

    I am in Fredericksburg Virginia. My son is an Electrician and came home today with a unique picture formed on old wood. Reads Buffalo Brewing company. It has a Woman sitting sideways on a Buffalo holding some grains in her one hand up w/ the other hand holding the bull. She has long dark hair and is wearing a mid length dress. Photo background has cream color w/what looks like a pillar/post behind the buffalo and her. At the bottom far right is Sacramento,Cal. USA. This was found in a old building in Old Town Alexandria, Virginia under construction. Does anyone have any information on this or would know someone with an interest in this piece?

  1. 5 Trackback(s)

  2. Feb 4, 2011: Editor’s Letter, February 2011 | Midtown Monthly
  3. Apr 10, 2011: Fans of local brews might like this. - Sacramento - California (CA) - City-Data Forum
  4. Aug 18, 2011: Sacramento’s Buffalo Chasers | Pacific Brew News
  5. Feb 16, 2012: Living Library 2/19: Ed Carroll, Beer Historian | Midtown Monthly
  6. Feb 26, 2016: Sacramento Beer Week: A Brief History Of Beer Here « New Country 105.1 FM – KNCI-FM Sacramento

Post a Comment